Search This Blog

Saturday, August 3, 2013

Is Man the Roof and Crown of God's creation?



We should first understand the differences between man and other creations of God in order to appreciate or renounce the ideology that man is the greatest of all creations. Let us explain this concept in view of the Quran which is the last of the scriptures in the Abrahamic or Semitic faith. 'Man-above-all' is a view highly regarded by the Judo-Christian faith, if not by other cultures all around the world. God speaks of the creation of mankind in allegorical terms as such:

Your Lord announced His Plan to the angels, “I am about to place on earth a new creation that will have supremacy over it.” They exclaimed, “Will you place on it such creation as will cause disorder therein and shed blood! - whereas we strive to manifest Your glory (in the Universe)!” He answered, “I know what you do not know.” And God endowed mankind with the capacity to attain knowledge. Then He showed the angels certain things and said to them, “Tell me if you have the capacity of learning about these, if you are truthful (and better qualified to have supremacy on the planet earth).” They humbly said, “Glorified are You, High above all! We only know what You have taught us (the tasks assigned to us). Most certainly, You, are all Knower, all Wise.”

Holy Quran, Ch. 2, V. 30-32
(English rendition by Dr. Shabbir Ahmed)

Knowledge and wisdom is what is unique to mankind. The capacity to think rationally and deduce from the abstract structure of the world the difference between truth and illusion, right and wrong, is what places us above all creations of God, as rulers of the planet Earth. In the language of science, homo sapiens are social animals. But there are other kinds of social animals too such as ants, bees and elephants. In fact, some creatures appear to be more social and altruistic than human beings. Take the example of squirrels. If a squirrel finds a forsaken infant squirrel it adopts the baby and raises it like its own child. Whereas even today some human beings dispose off their own girl infants in dustbins and never look behind. However compassion is as natural as violence. The famous biologist Richard Dawkins remarks,

“I shall argue that a predominant quality to be expected in a successful gene is ruthless selfishness. This gene selfishness will usually give rise to selfishness in individual behavior. However, as we shall see, there are special circumstances in which a gene can achieve its own selfish goals best by fostering a limited form of altruism at the level of individual animals.”

It is indeed a scientifically proven fact that everyone of us are selfish by virtue of our genetic instincts. No matter however generous and altruistic an animal might seem at first sight, deep down inside its genes are serving some selfish purpose. But there is a huge difference when it comes to human beings. We can choose to be different. We are endowed with the power to act different from what millions of years of evolution has brought us to. To quote the words of Richard Dawkins again,

“Be warned that if you wish, as I do, to build a society in which individuals cooperate generously and unselfishly towards a common good, you can expect little help from biological nature. Let us try to teach generosity and altruism, because we are born selfish. Let us understand what our own genes are up to, because we may then at least have the chance to upset their designs, something that no other species has ever aspired to.”

And that is exactly what makes us the roof and crown of God's creation – our intelligent choices!

Therefore the real question to ask is this: do we act today like the roof and crown of God's creation is supposed to act? Are we making wise and intelligent choices?

No, we are not! We are not using our brains these days. We are giving in to our basic animal instincts and forgetting who we truly are. The world is not at peace. There is violence all over. People are divided, each with their own set of beliefs and dogmas, intolerable towards other people who share a different opinion. This is all the result of ignorance and a mockery of human wisdom. Mankind is capable of doing miracles – setting voyages out for infinite space, traveling unimaginable distances at the blink of an eye, creating machines that can think and dream, and many such wonders that are yet to be witnessed in future. Art and science are but signatures of mankind's noble design. But as Voltaire said, “with great power comes great responsibility.” We must understand that. See what we have made of ourselves. Look upon history and you will find a world soaked in blood and gore. God made just one mankind. We made the Hindus, Muslims, Christians and Jews. God gave us one planet to live in. We made India, Pakistan, America and Iran. Lo and behold! We are fighting our own kind and gradually moving towards the destruction of this majestic race called mankind. We are blinded by some persistent delusion that makes us think that we are obliged by some divine command to murder innocent people, rape their women, slaughter their children, pillage their cities and leave them burning.

See what Hitler did to the Jews. The Nazi bureaucrats sat together and worked out ways for the systematic slaughtering of all the Jews in Europe. Almost fifty million people were killed because of the war waged by Hitler – the World War II. Nearly twenty three million innocent civilians who wanted nothing but a simple life of peace, were brutally killed. Nearly six million Jews were murdered mercilessly in unimaginable barbarian ways. One million gypsies, Jehovah's witnesses, homosexuals, political dissidents and the disabled were murdered. Of the nearly seven million thus murdered, more than one and a half million were innocent children who knew nothing of the world.

This kind of tyranny is not new or old. Take for example the cannibalism and bloodbaths of the “Holy” Crusades. Of all the religious wars that have ever been waged in the history of mankind, none have been more bloodier, more genocidal and more barbaric than the two-hundred-year “holy war” by the Western Crusaders against the Arabs and Muslims. Their motive was simple and clear: to cleanse the holy land of Palestine and its vicinity by murdering all the Arabs (whether Muslim or Jew) “...on the ground that they had no right to inhabit their part of the earth, while for a Christian the whole world is his country.” (James David Barber)

Take the recent communists for an example too. Their goal was noble: to achieve an utopia where there was no poor and no rich, and everybody lived as equals in peace. See what they did in the name of this cause. In less than a hundred years, communism has claimed more than hundred million lives. Hundreds of thousands of Cossacks were destroyed. Forced famine was introduced in Ukraine and more than six million people were starved to death. Mao murdered tens of millions of Chinese peasants for this cause in his “Great Leap Forward”. Eight hundred and fifty thousand Vietnamese were sent to their graves in education camps. Many such atrocities happened in the name of socialism.

The United States' eleven years of aggression against countries like Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Pakistan, Yemen and now Syria, have resulted in civilian deaths far in excess of military casualties. Then we have the tyranny of the terrorists too! There is no need to light much upon this topic because everybody knows. Most of the terrorist organizations in the world are Muslim. Islam is seen as a fascist and violent religion because of these people. There are other groups of terrorists too, like the Maoists and Naxals in India. The oppression on Muslims in countries like Burma and Myanmar is also well known. The religious bigotry between the Hindus and Muslims is a classic example. In 1984, more than four thousand Sikh men, women and children were slaughtered. Women were raped while their terrified families pleaded for mercy, little or none of which was shown. In 2002, Hindu fundamentalists carried out a genocidal ethnic cleansing of Muslims in Gujarat. Nearly twenty thousand Muslims were brutally killed. Over one hundred forty thousand were thrown out of their lands. Businesses and houses were burned. And thousands of women were gang raped and burned alive.

As long as we do not learn to rise above our animal instincts, we cannot call ourselves the best of creations. Indeed we have proved ourselves before God to be the meanest of all creations. Sigh!

“Surely, greater than the creation of the humans, is the creation of the heavens and the earth. But most people never know (what it implies).”
Holy Quran, Ch. 40, V. 57
(English rendition by Dr. Shabbir Ahmed)

Thursday, April 11, 2013

How good is Christ University, Bangalore, esp. for a BSc degree?

It's been one year since I joined this college for a BSc course, and I will tell you my honest opinions about this college, because I want you to get your facts right and be careful lest you fall into a trap without enough information.

I am very passionate about physics and I had this dream of getting into the Massachusetts Institute of Technology there at the United States but it was too great an ambition for me and I could not realise this dream unless I first got an undergraduate degree from India, then maybe I thought I could apply for a graduate program there later on. That would be more affordable I thought.

(By the way, I became a fan of MIT after I watched some really awesome lectures by Prof. Walter Lewin from the MIT OpenCourseWare website. I highly recommend you to watch them.)

THE GREATEST MISTAKE I DID WAS BEING AWFULLY LESS INFORMED! You ought to do a lot of research before you join any college, which I did not do. I applied to a lot of colleges here at Bangalore, but when I entered the campus of Christ University, I was blinded by its awesome infrastructure and greenery. The campus was so well maintained, and as I went inside the Central Block in order to get the admission form, I was mesmerised by the looks of the walls, the lifts and the shining floor. I even liked the bathroom a lot. I wished in my heart and prayed that I should get admitted only in this college and nowhere else.

Even today I have positive feelings towards the campus and infrastructure of Christ University. There's everything: the Bird's Park, the gym and even a small kind of a mall inside Gourmet. And you have nice food courts too. I love that aspect of Christ University. Sit in the park under the shades after lunch and plug some music into your ears, and enjoy the fresh wind blowing at you. That's a nice feeling.

By the way I got admitted into St. Joseph's  college too, and I even attended one class there. But I din't like the classroom there, nor the campus. I din't even know there was an observatory in that college, and it was much better than Christ University in terms of science studies. I thought after all Christ is ranked as one of the top ten colleges in India and by the looks of it, it ought to be much better than this.

I was wrong. I made the dumbest decision of my life. First of all, there is no Physics honors here. You have to give equal weightage on all the three subjects (Physics, Math and Chemistry/Electronics). And it's a damn three years course which is in no ways equivalent to a US bachelor's degree.

See I'm fcuked up now!

I ought to have applied for an honors course in Bangalore University, if I had to stay here at all. They have this four years integrated BS course quite similar to that of IISc but much more easier to get into. I met two students taking this course a few months back, and I learned that they were doing a project in which they were trying to build a cyclotron under the guidance of their teacher and funded by the university because there's a lot of money going into it. That was so cool. Do you know what we do here at Christ University?

We come to class only for the sake of attendance and meeting our friends. That's all. Even most of my classmates are nerds basically. But don't you ever think they are intelligent intellectuals or something, because they are not. They mug up formulas and stuff, cram up all the notes fed by teachers for the sake of passing the semester, and may be getting good decent marks sometimes. But that is all they do, these goddamn slaves of teachers! I do not see education here. (I must tell you I have some exceptional friends though.)

And the teachers, I should tell you about them. The entire Physics department is full of shit people, hypocrites basically! There is only one exception to them I think. He never came to teach us Physics, but I found the passion in him, the craving for knowledge that defines a scientist. I like him. Apart from him, the others are just plain bull's shit, trust me. If you love Physics, for God's sake, never come here. You might end up losing your interest in Physics at all.

The Mathematics department is better though. They have a monopoly here in all things. And they offer you an honors course too. I have no complains against this department. (Mind you! There are exceptions in every damn thing in this world.)

I think apart from the department I am most interested in, the other ones such as humanities and management etc are really awesome. I only came across the English department because I have to learn this subject for the first four semesters, and I loved the teachers. They are just so awesome people, so passionate about their work and really wise educated beings who can inspire you to do something.

I think if you are doing anything besides science, I must recommend Christ University to you. (I don't take the responsibility though.)

By the way, I must tell you the Library here is really good. If you genuinely want some education, you find it here only.

This is my experience at Christ University after one year. Hoping to see better things from next semester.

Thursday, August 23, 2012

Tipu


(Tipu, a 15 years old boy, walks home from school)

Tasnim: Tipu! Tipu! Wait...

Tipu (Turns back): Hey Tassy, whats up? :) Hi Brad. Whats up Jay?

(They continue walking)

Tasnim: Why did you do that today?

Tipu: Do what?

Jay: Mess with the teachers! It's not right.

Tipu: Oh! That history teacher? That fool does not understand me. Haha..

Tasnim: I know you are good in the natural sciences, no! Maybe the best of us, but that does not mean every other subject is nonsense. How can you call him a fool? Look at yourself. He's got a PhD. And you? How dare you compare? (Looks away, angry.)

Tipu (Laughs mockingly): Oh why, dint you see how he lost his nerves and started yelling at me when I was only trying to put some sense into him. Is that how a sane man behaves? He says legends of kings and stories of wars and the exact dates and all those stuffs of the past are necessary to understand the present. I remarked, let the dead past bury its dead, while... (interrupted)

Brad: I know sweetheart. You dont have to lecture again. I was there.

Tasnim: Why Tipu, at least study for exams' sake. You will fail if you stick to this attitude. Teachers are important.

Tipu (Smiles): Knowledge is.

Brad: No, wisdom is more important. That comes with experience. We are only children. Why dont you understand this? We are ignorant of many complex realities of life. Teachers are not to be ignored. They have the experience of life.

Tipu: That's a belief fed to us by these elderly blockheads. They have grown old. And that which you call experience is rust that has made them so resistant to new ideas and new attitudes. That way progress cannot come. Progress is a change – a goodly change. That comes with innovation and creative thinking. Tell me what's the point in remembering by heart the dates of history? You can always look them up in the internet.

Jay: O I second you Mr. Einstein, so exactly how are you going to bring the change? Proving E equals m c squared wrong? (Giggles)

Tasnim: You get passed with excellent marks if you have a good memory. Simple as that! :)

Brad: However there are clear reasons why we must respect our teachers, why we must try to learn from them as much as we can. At this age, we cannot do anything on our own. I think on some issues we are trying to be oversmart.

(Tipu stops walking. Looks into Brad's eyes.)

Tipu (unhappy): Show me ample reasons if you think we are being oversmart. Let me also see if we are indeed. We dont have to worry though. Truth always stands clear from error. We only need to have a clear unbiased unprejudiced scientific mind.

Tasnim (pulling on Tipu's hands): Oh common Tipu!

Tipu: I am sorry.
(Tipu resumes walking)

Tipu: I do not say I am always right. To err is human. But what I say is, this applies to them as well. They are not some kind of gods from heaven.

Brad: Yeah. But we are arrogant in our understanding and interpretation. Sort of disrespecting the intellect of the greybeards. I dont like that.

Tipu (smiles): “Blind respect for authority is the worst enemy of truth.” Einstein.

Jay: Dont you respect Einstein, even though his theory is flawed at some point? Does not imply that he is a complete old fool.

Brad: Yeah!

Tipu: I dont care about Einstein. What matters me is his ideas. I judge his works, not his person. Not blind respect, but recognition for what is worthy in him. Same applies to everybody else.

Though his theories have no flaws to correct you. ;)

Brad: Yeah. So for one flaw, will you disregard all of his claims and theories? No. You are obtuse and you dont wish to learn and disregard things which does not suit you.

Tasnim (chuckles): Right.

Jay: Point! :D

Tipu (embarrassed): If his claims and theories are not related to this flaw or are not derived from the flaw, they are a separate world, and I have no reasons to reject them adamantly. Anyway, the greybeards with their heavy heads are not smart enough to be human. PS If they have something good in them, they get their due respect.

Brad: You have ingrained hatred for authority and greybeards which has nothing to do with their credibility. You are inclined towards rebellion. At times, unnecessary! Disregarding someone unfit to be humans is a contempt which I feel displays vanity. Brother, do respect them. Because you have a clear perspective on things, it's your responsibility to spread it, not picking up fights with greybeards just 'cause they cant dye their beard black, and understand the different perspective you so ardently follow.

Tipu: I hate no man. But I cannot stand... (interrupted)

Tasnim (with gravity): Enough is enough! Here Tipu, you have reached home. Go get some sleep. For God's sake do the homeworks today. Bye. See you tomorrow.

(Tipu enters gate. Friends leave. End of scene.)

Sunday, April 15, 2012

A Child's Approach to the Quantisation of Space


We will not define space (or the more fundamental concept of position) here, but rather will try to discuss on the issue of whether there are any elements of space that could be eliminated. We know that space is the set of all possible positions of any physical system, and it exists because of the way systems exhibit changes in position as an inherent property or in response to physical forces. Space does exist, because of perceived changes in position. Therefore, we may take a probe-system and see what the possible changes in position are during its motion and thus define space operationally. If, however, we discover some regions of the predicted space that show unobservable changes in position, we may render that as a thing to be eliminated from the theory. Space does not exist, because of unperceived changes in position. Now, the perception of position is made possible by radiation; most commonly, it is the visible range of the electromagnetic spectrum – “light” (a magnificent element of the universe, as fundamental as space and time). However, any radiation such as gravitational waves could be used to measure positions (in common words, just by ‘feeling’ the gravity we could tell that there was something over there). So we see that the existence of space is fundamentally determined by the perception of radiation. Space does exist, because of perceived radiation.

But, according to Plank’s quantum theory, all radiation must be discontinuous consisting of distinguishable individual tiny packets of the radiation, the energy of each packet varying linearly as the frequency of the radiation. This little fact adds a new turn here. The quantization of radiation is perceived, if and only if the time lag between every two consecutive packets of the radiation is perceived to be a non-zero quantity. The time lag being zero implies the radiation being continuous. So the corollary is: this time lag without which radiation is continuous, between two successive quanta of radiation eliminates the space of observation in between. This, it seems, breaks the continuity of space. The space vs. time plot of our probe-system moving across space would exhibit periodic dark splashes in time when the radiations breaks because of quantization and so does our perception of space which is due to radiation. For all practical purposes, this breakdown of the continuum of space would be in so negligibly small scales that we would not notice it in our daily life. It must be noted here that the information of the positions of our probe-system during the said time lags would be completely lost. One of my colleagues argued that radiation is not the only means of conveying the information of positions of objects in motion: we could for instance, measure the entropy change of the universe during these time lags and thus retrieve the information of where the object has been during that time. But the problem here is that even entropy changes are due to energy transactions which are fundamentally quantized. Therefore it is apparent that whatever means is taken to measure changes in position, the dark splashes in time are an intrinsic part of a complete description of motion. Space is kind of quantized in time.

            Here is a rough sketch of what the space vs. time plot of a uniformly moving object would look like at extremely tiny scales.


             Note in the figure that the dark splashes are periodic in nature. And we lose information of the graph in those splashes. It is to be remembered that the dark splashes are the collapse of perception in times when there is no radiation due to quantization.

            Let us now make a quantitative evaluation of some specific case regarding this issue. We have talked on length about time lag between successive quanta of radiation. Let us now determine experimentally a very rough estimate of the time lag between two successive photons of known frequency ‘f’. We take a certain amount of a gas, say ‘N’ molecules of it, which has reasonably ideal behavior and put it in a container that maintains isochoric conditions at all times. We assume that the degrees of freedom of the gas molecules are ‘σ’ and the Newton’s cooling constant associated with it is ‘K’. Now we expose the gas to an environment that has a temperature equal to ‘Ta’, and shine monochromatic light of frequency ‘f’ on it as the only external source of heat transfer to the gas. At some point of time we measure the temperature of the gas to be equal to ‘T0’, and exactly after a time interval ‘t’ we again measure the temperature of the gas and find it to be equal to ‘T’. These data that we have collected can predict the time lag ‘τ’ between two successive photons according to the following equation.
$$ \tau \approx - \frac{2hf}{\sigma N K k \Delta T} \log \Big( \frac{T - T_a}{T_0 - T_a} \Big) $$
where,              $h$ = Plank’s constant,     $k$ = Boltzmann constant,     $\Delta T = T - T_0$.
If we conduct the experiment in empty space, the equation would reduce to the following.
$$ \tau \approx - \frac{2hf}{\sigma N K k \Delta T} \log \Big( \frac{T }{T_0} \Big)$$
According to Newton’s law of cooling,
$$ T(t) = T_a + (T_0 - T_a) e^{-Kt} \\ i.e. \quad t = -\frac1K \log  \Big( \frac{T - T_a}{T_0 - T_a} \Big) $$
We know from the laws of thermodynamics that during an isochoric change in temperature, the corresponding change in total internal energy of the gas is governed by the following equation.
$$ \Delta E = \frac12 \sigma Nk\Delta T $$
This change in energy is due to the energy delivered by the incoming photons. If ‘n’ photons were required to produce the above energy, then by Plank’s equation we have the following.
$$ \Delta E = nhf $$
Equating the two, we can solve for ‘n’.
$$ \frac12 \sigma Nk\Delta T = nhf \\ i.e. \quad n = \frac12 \frac{\sigma Nk\Delta T}{hf} $$
Now we know how many photons arrived in how much time. Therefore if we distribute the photons evenly over the time interval, we can measure the spacing in time between two successive photons. So we have the following.
$$ \tau = \frac{t}{n} \\ i.e. \quad \tau = \frac{-\frac1K \log  \Big( \frac{T - T_a}{T_0 - T_a} \Big)}{\frac12 \frac{\sigma Nk\Delta T}{hf}} \\ i.e. \quad \tau = - \frac{2hf}{\sigma N K k \Delta T} \log \Big( \frac{T - T_a}{T_0 - T_a} \Big) $$
This is how we arrived at the equation. Please note here that we have derived the above relation based on Newton’s law of cooling which is only an approximate description of the phenomenon and is at most times inaccurate and a merely a very rough estimate. Hence the truest thing to write would be the following. $$ \tau \approx - \frac{2hf}{\sigma N K k \Delta T} \log \Big( \frac{T - T_a}{T_0 - T_a} \Big) $$
Note here that the negative sign has here popped in because we have implemented Newton's law of "cooling" on a "heating" effect. Therefore the negative sign can be ignored and dropped without any logical blunder. That gives the magnitude of the required time. Obviously, negative time has no meaning at all.

I do not have the apparatus or any means to conduct the experiment. Therefore I go no further. In thought experiments, we have seen that it is possible to estimate, although very roughly the time lag that exists between two successive photons and determines the breakdown of the continuity of space.



[This text is an excerpt from a project I completed last year, March 14, 2011]